EDHEC-Risk finds no new evidence that Socially Responsible Investment Funds create financial value
13 September 2010
EDHEC recommends that SRI be integrated in a more global process whereby the results of 50 years of quantitative research in finance are not abandoned in favour of a solely qualitative approach.
In 2008, EDHEC-Risk Institute analysed the performance of a sample of SRI funds distributed in France, covering a six year-period from January 2002 to December 2007. This study concluded that none of the funds in the sample produced both positive and statistically significant alpha.
In a new position paper entitled “The Performance of Socially Responsible Investment and Sustainable Development in France: an Update after the Financial Crisis”, EDHEC-Risk Institute again finds that a majority of the funds studied over long or short periods produce negative but non-significant alpha.
· To highlight the period of the financial crisis, the new study examines SRI funds over both a fairly long period, with 8 years of data, ending in December 2009, and a shorter period of 3 years, including data from January 2007 to December 2009.
· Including the period of the financial crisis increases the extreme risks borne by SRI funds considerably; it is clear that, on average, these funds provide no protection from market downturns.
· The study confirms EDHEC-Risk Institute’s previous results on SRI as presented in the 2008 position paper. At this stage it has not been shown that the SRI approach on its own creates value in the financial sense of the term.
· This does not mean that extra-financial criteria should not be taken into account, but they cannot be the only foundation for sound portfolio management.
EDHEC recommends that SRI be integrated in a more global process whereby the results of 50 years of quantitative research in finance are not abandoned in favour of a solely qualitative approach. As such, an approach that combines stock picking with SRI criteria and a well-diversified portfolio construction methodology can be an alternative to pure SRI, which is often practised with relative risk constraints linked to poorly diversified and inefficient cap-weighted indices.
© EDHEC
